
The untaxed figure is something you work out yourself, and it matters for FAFSA, for basis tracking, and for rollovers. A wrong number can mean overpaid tax or a financial aid verification request. "Untaxed" also doesn't always mean tax-free forever.
This guide covers how Form 1099-R, Form 8606, and rollovers fit together, how to calculate the difference, and why Australian superannuation needs separate treatment.
Key Takeaways
- Form 1040 reports total and taxable IRA distributions; the untaxed amount is derived.
- Check Form 1099-R, prior Form 8606 filings, and rollover records before calculating.
- Nondeductible contributions, rollovers, and qualified Roth distributions can reduce the taxable amount.
- Australian super is not automatically a US IRA and needs its own analysis.
What Does "Untaxed Portion" Mean?
The key terms
- Gross distribution: the total amount paid out (Form 1099-R, box 1).
- Taxable amount: the part included in income (box 2a, if the payer determined it).
- Untaxed or nontaxable portion: the gross amount minus the taxable amount.
- Withholding: tax paid in advance (box 4). It is not a measure of what's taxable.
- Rollover: money moved to another eligible retirement account within the allowed rules.
The basic calculation is line 4a minus line 4b. Then you review the result, because the gap may include rollovers or other exclusions under that year's instructions.
Untaxed is not the same as tax-free forever
An amount may be excluded from current income because it is after-tax basis or a qualifying rollover. A rollover simply defers tax until later withdrawals. Basis, by contrast, has already been taxed.
Keep these concepts apart as well:
- Federal taxability
- The early-distribution additional tax
- Federal withholding
- FAFSA's definition of untaxed income
A hypothetical example
Suppose line 4a shows $20,000 and line 4b shows $14,000. The difference is $6,000. That $6,000 might be:
- Basis recovered from nondeductible contributions
- A rollover completed within 60 days
- A mix of both
Which one it is changes the FAFSA treatment, so confirm it against your records before using the figure anywhere.
How to Find and Calculate the Amount on Form 1040
Documents and records to gather
- The Form 1040 for the correct tax year
- Every Form 1099-R received
- Rollover confirmations
- IRA account statements
- Prior Forms 8606 and records of nondeductible contributions
Verify the tax year first. Line numbers and instructions change, and the IRS's 2026 Form 1040 is a draft marked "not for filing." The 2025 Form 1040 instructions apply to 2025 returns.
Matching Form 1099-R to Form 1040
- Box 1: gross distribution
- Box 2a: taxable amount, when the payer determined it
- Box 4: federal tax withheld
- Box 7: distribution code
IRA figures generally flow to lines 4a and 4b. For a fully taxable distribution, the instructions say to enter it on 4b and leave 4a blank. For a rollover, report the gross amount on 4a and generally enter zero on 4b if everything was rolled over.
Don't trust box 2a blindly. Payers often can't determine an owner's basis, so box 2b may show the taxable amount as not determined. Withholding doesn't reduce the gross distribution or decide what's taxable.
Calculating and validating the amount
- Identify total IRA distributions from every Form 1099-R.
- Determine the taxable amount under current IRS rules.
- Subtract the taxable amount from the gross to find the untaxed portion.
- Separate out qualifying rollovers.
- Reconcile the result to your supporting records.

The pro-rata rule. If you made nondeductible contributions, Form 8606 allocates basis across all your traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs combined. You generally can't pull out only the after-tax dollars from one account.
A withdrawal from an account holding after-tax money can still be partly taxable. The Form 8606 instructions walk through the line-by-line calculation.
Final accuracy checklist:
- Document both direct and 60-day rollovers
- Analyse Roth distributions separately
- Flag inherited IRAs
- Reconstruct missing Form 8606 records rather than assuming zero basis
- Confirm Form 1099-R matches what you filed
A missed Form 8606 for a nondeductible contribution can carry a $50 penalty.
How IRA Distributions Become Fully or Partly Taxable
| IRA type | Typical treatment |
|---|---|
| Traditional | Generally taxable, reduced by basis |
| SEP / SIMPLE | Treated as traditional for Form 8606; employer contributions aren't basis |
| Roth | Qualified distributions may be tax-free; others need ordering analysis |
| Inherited | Depends on beneficiary type and original account |
Basis, rollovers, and penalties
Nondeductible traditional contributions create basis. The taxable/nontaxable split comes from Form 8606, not just the custodian's Form 1099-R.
A properly completed rollover is not an ordinary cash distribution. The 60-day deadline applies, and the one-rollover-per-year limit generally applies across all your IRAs. Trustee-to-trustee transfers and Roth conversions are exempt from that limit.
The 10% early-distribution additional tax is separate from regular income tax. It generally applies to the taxable portion before age 59½ unless an exception applies, and a SIMPLE IRA withdrawal within two years of joining can trigger 25%. Check the Form 5329 instructions for current exceptions.

Roth, RMDs, and withholding
A Roth distribution is generally qualified after the five-tax-year period plus a trigger such as age 59½, disability, death, or a qualifying first-home purchase. Nonqualified distributions come out in order: contributions, then conversions, then earnings.
Required minimum distributions, withholding, and the taxable amount are three separate questions. Review each on its own.
How to Report the Untaxed Portion When Completing FAFSA
FAFSA 2026–27 uses 2024 tax return data, mostly transferred from the IRS through the FA-DDX exchange. The untaxed IRA amount is generally Form 1040 line 4a minus line 4b, with rollovers identified separately.
That's why you shouldn't type in the full Form 1099-R box 1 figure. A qualified rollover shouldn't count as untaxed income once properly identified, and the IRS data transfer doesn't reliably flag rollovers on its own.
Verification checklist:
- Form 1040
- Forms 1099-R
- Form 8606
- Rollover confirmations
- A signed, dated statement explaining the rollover amount
FAFSA reporting isn't the same as calculating federal tax. Use the current FAFSA wording and Federal Student Aid Handbook for the relevant award year.
Australian and Cross-Border Considerations
Super is not automatically an IRA
An Australian superannuation fund is created under Australian law. Both are retirement savings vehicles, but that doesn't make Form 8606's basis formula apply.
US treatment depends on legal classification, contributions, distributions, taxpayer status, and treaty provisions. US guidance on these points is limited.
An SMSF may also raise foreign-trust questions. The US–Australia treaty has a pensions article, but its application turns on how the benefit is classified. The saving clause can still preserve US taxation of US citizens.
Australian labels don't translate
The ATO's "tax-free component" and "taxable component" are Australian concepts. They aren't interchangeable with Form 1040's taxable amount or FAFSA's untaxed IRA distributions. An amount untaxed in Australia may still need separate US analysis.
Foreign reporting
- FBAR: generally required if foreign accounts exceeded $10,000 in aggregate at any point in the year
- Form 8938: depends on residence, filing status, and asset thresholds
- Forms 3520/3520-A: may apply if the arrangement is a foreign trust

Reporting doesn't automatically make a distribution taxable. These are information filings, separate from income tax.
When professional review may help
Get a review if your return includes:
- Australian superannuation
- Multiple IRAs
- Missing Form 8606 filings
- Indirect rollovers
- Inherited accounts
- Conflicting Form 1099-R data
VJM Global's US-trained CPAs and Chartered Accountants can assist Australian-based taxpayers with Form 1040 preparation, FBAR and Form 8938 reporting, and cross-border documentation review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where do I enter IRA distributions on 1040?
Total IRA distributions generally go on line 4a and the taxable amount on line 4b. Line numbers can change, so confirm them in the instructions for your tax year.
What do untaxed portions of IRA distributions mean?
It generally means the part of a reported distribution not included in taxable income. The reason may be basis, a rollover, or another rule.
How do I calculate the untaxed portion of an IRA distribution?
Start with total distributions minus the taxable amount. Then check for rollovers, Form 8606 basis, and current IRS or FAFSA instructions.
Are IRA rollovers included in the untaxed portion?
A qualifying rollover appears in the 4a-minus-4b gap, but FAFSA treats it separately from untaxed income. Keep rollover confirmations to support that.
How do nondeductible IRA contributions affect the taxable amount?
After-tax basis can reduce the taxable portion. Form 8606 and the pro-rata rule generally determine the result.
How are Australian superannuation distributions treated on a US Form 1040?
It depends on the arrangement's US classification, your filing status, contributions, the distribution, and treaty terms. Foreign reporting may also apply.