
This article covers the U.S. IRS underpayment penalty, not Australian PAYG obligations. We explain when the penalty applies, how quarterly shortfalls are calculated, the safe harbours, Form 2210, the exceptions, and what to do next. Amounts are in U.S. dollars (US$) because the IRS assesses them in that currency.
Key Takeaways
- The penalty is about when you paid during the year, not only the final balance.
- Withholding and estimated payments are tested against safe-harbour rules and instalment dates.
- IRS calculations cover most returns; Form 2210 handles annualisation, waivers and special cases.
- Check current IRS quarterly rates and thresholds before quoting any figure.
What Is the 1040 Underpayment Penalty?
The 1040 underpayment penalty is an IRS charge under IRC section 6654 for not paying enough federal income tax through withholding or estimated payments as income is earned. The IRS calculates it from the amount underpaid, how long it stayed unpaid, and the quarterly rate in the IRS Form 2210 instructions.
The amount appears on line 38 ("Estimated tax penalty") of the 2024 and 2025 Form 1040. Confirm the line number if you file for a different year.
Paying everything by the filing deadline does not erase it. If an earlier instalment was late or too small, the penalty still applies to that period.
Who may be affected?
Anyone with income that isn't fully covered by withholding:
- Self-employed people and contractors
- Investors and landlords
- Commission earners
- People receiving bonuses or retirement distributions
- Households with two earners or multiple jobs
For Australian-based filers, the rules match those for taxpayers in the U.S. U.S. citizens and resident aliens abroad have the same estimated-tax requirements, according to IRS Publication 54.
The automatic extension to 15 June extends filing, not payment. Tax and the first estimated instalment are still due 15 April.
Foreign tax is the other trap. Tax paid to Australia can support a foreign tax credit, usually claimed on Form 1116. It is not a payment remitted to the IRS toward a Form 1040-ES instalment, so don't assume ATO payments satisfy U.S. timing rules. Treaty and credit facts vary by person, so have them reviewed.
Underpayment penalty versus other IRS charges
| Charge | Trigger | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated-tax underpayment | Insufficient or late instalments | Quarterly IRS rate, by instalment period |
| Failure to pay | Tax unpaid after due date | 0.5% per month, capped at 25% |
| Failure to file | Late return | 5% per month, capped at 25% |
Each has its own trigger, calculation and relief options. Don't treat them as one penalty.
How Is the 1040 Underpayment Penalty Calculated?
The IRS applies a four-step framework:
- Work out the required annual payment.
- Split it across the instalment periods.
- Compare each required amount with what you paid.
- Charge interest on each shortfall for the days it remained unpaid.
What counts and when
For 2025, the required annual payment is generally the smaller of 90% of 2025 tax or 100% of 2024 tax. Use 110% of 2024 tax if 2024 AGI exceeded $150,000 ($75,000 if married filing separately). Four equal instalments fall due on 15 April, 15 June, 15 September 2025 and 15 January 2026.

Counted payments include:
- Withholding
- Estimated payments
- Prior-year overpayments applied forward
- Payments made with the return
A late estimated payment counts from the date it's made. Withholding is normally treated as paid evenly across the instalment dates, though you can elect actual withholding dates on Form 2210 (Part II, box D) if that lowers the penalty.
The rate
The individual rate is the US federal short-term rate plus 3 percentage points, compounded daily. The 2026 rates on the IRS quarterly rates page are:
| Quarter | Rate |
|---|---|
| Q1 | 7% |
| Q2 | 6% |
| Q3 | 7% |
| Q4 | 7% |
Rates change by quarter, so never apply one quarter's rate to the whole year. Check the page for your tax year.
Hypothetical example
These figures are invented and rounded. Two taxpayers each owe a $12,000 required annual payment, so $3,000 per instalment. Both pay $12,000 in total.
- Taxpayer A pays $3,000 on each due date. No penalty.
- Taxpayer B pays nothing until January, then $12,000. Penalties accrue on each missed $3,000 instalment from its due date until payment.
Same annual total, different penalty. Timing decides it.

Automatic calculation or Form 2210
The IRS generally computes the penalty and sends a notice, and most filers don't attach Form 2210. You need the form if a Part II reason applies, such as a waiver, annualised income, or actual withholding dates.
How Can You Avoid or Reduce the Penalty?
The safe harbours
You generally avoid the penalty by paying through withholding and estimates at least:
- 90% of current-year tax, or
- 100% of prior-year tax (110% for higher earners, per the thresholds above)
The prior year must have covered 12 months. The 2025 Form 2210 also provides no penalty where tax owed after withholding is under $1,000. For 2026 estimates, the IRS expects payments when you'll owe at least $1,000 after withholding and credits.
Practical levers
- Employees: update Form W-4 and use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator.
- Self-employed and investors: pay via Form 1040-ES vouchers or the IRS online account.
- Couples: review the combined household position, especially when incomes or withholding differ.
- Life changes: recalculate after a new contract, asset sale, bonus, retirement distribution or job change.
Nonresident aliens use Form 1040-ES (NR), which follows a different process.
If you're already behind
- Make a catch-up payment now. It stops further accrual.
- Increase eligible withholding if you have wages.
- File on time, even if you can't pay in full.
- Pay what you can and check the IRS payment plans page for any remaining balance.

Form 2210, Exceptions, and Responding to an IRS Notice
When Form 2210 helps
Part II of the 2025 form covers these options:
- A: Request a full waiver
- B: Request a partial waiver
- C: Annualised income using Schedule AI
- D: Actual withholding dates
- E: A specified joint-return mismatch between years
Schedule AI
Annualisation suits uneven income: seasonal business earnings, a late-year capital gain, a large bonus, commissions or a big retirement distribution. It can reduce or eliminate earlier instalments. If used, it applies to all periods and is attached with Form 2210.
Waivers and exceptions
Reasonable cause alone usually won't waive this penalty. Relief may apply where:
- Casualty, disaster or other unusual circumstances make the penalty unfair
- You retired after age 62 (within two years) or became disabled, and had reasonable cause
- You're a farmer or fisher with at least two-thirds of gross income from that work, and you file and pay by the early-March deadline (2 March 2026 for tax year 2025)

Submit a waiver request as a signed written explanation to the address on your notice.
Notice-response checklist
Before paying or disputing, compare the notice against:
- Your filed Form 1040 and Form 2210
- Payment confirmations and estimated-payment dates
- Withholding records
- Any prior-year credit applied
Look for calculation errors first. If a CP30A notice says the IRS reduced the penalty and you disagree, call the number on it with your records ready.
Getting help
VJM Global's U.S. tax compliance and Form 1040 support helps Australian-based taxpayers and international business owners review estimated payments, cross-border income, Form 2210 and IRS notices. The team compiles supporting documents and drafts responses. No review can promise a penalty will be eliminated, but a second look often catches timing mistakes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a tax underpayment penalty?
It's an IRS charge for paying too little federal tax, or paying late, through withholding or estimated payments during the year. It applies even if you settle the balance at filing.
How is the 1040 underpayment penalty calculated?
The IRS looks at each instalment shortfall, the quarterly rate, and how long the shortfall lasted. Form 2210 contains the detailed calculation.
What is the current IRS underpayment penalty rate?
It changes quarterly. The 2026 individual rates are 7%, 6%, 7% and 7% for Q1 to Q4, but check the IRS Quarterly Interest Rates page for your quarter.
How can I avoid the 1040 underpayment penalty?
Meet a safe harbour: 90% of current-year tax or 100% of prior-year tax (110% above the AGI threshold). Keep withholding accurate and pay estimates on time.
How do I know if I have a tax underpayment penalty?
Look at line 38 of the Form 1040, your tax software output, or an IRS notice. The IRS may calculate its own figure separately.
What happens if I owe taxes on my 1040?
An ordinary balance due isn't the same as the underpayment penalty. File on time, pay as much as you can, and look at a payment plan or professional help for the rest.