在中央邦高等法院 2018 年 7 月 5 日的裁决中,由于未按规定填写电子运单(E-way Bill)门户网站的 B 部分,GST 上诉机构、印多尔邦税务联合专员及印多尔邦税务助理专员对 Gati Kintetsu Express Pvt Ltd 公司处以 13,213,683 卢比罚款的决定得到维持。
与电子运单门户网站 B 部分相关的案情事实:
- Gati Kintetsu Express Pvt Ltd 的车辆当时正运载货物从马哈拉施特拉邦浦那(Wadki)经由印多尔等地前往诺伊达。2018 年 4 月 27 日,相关部门对该车辆进行了检查。经询问,车辆驾驶员(运输负责人)出示了账单和货运单。在查询电子运单时发现,负责运输货物的申请人(运输公司)未上传或更新电子运单的 B 部分,而这是强制性要求。此举违反了《2017 年中央商品及服务税法》(CGST Act 2017)第 68 条及第 138 条规则的规定。因此,当局根据该法第 129 条启动了程序,并因其在无相关文件证明的情况下运输应税货物,根据该法第 122 条处以罚款。
Gati Kintetsu Express Pvt Ltd 提出的理由
- Gati Kintetsu Express Pvt Ltd 辩称,申请人在货物或服务的跨邦及邦内供应过程中并无逃税意图,且由于技术故障,无法更新电子运单的 B 部分。这一理由被驳回,理由是 GST 门户网站为申请人在更新电子运单 B 部分时遇到问题提供了申诉选项。申请人并未提出此类申诉,且在未提交书面申诉的情况下,有关技术故障的说法不予采信。若未更新 B 部分,则电子运单不具备真实性或合法性;因此,在 GST 门户网站本身提供申诉渠道的情况下,未填写电子运单门户网站的 B 部分不能被视为轻微过失或技术错误。
根据《中央商品及服务税法》(CGST)第 68 条及第 138 条规则的规定,每位运输价值超过 50,000 卢比货物的注册人员,均需在货物运输开始前,在通用门户网站的电子运单 A 部分提供货物详情,并在电子运单门户网站的 B 部分提供运输工具详情。
若未能提供电子运单门户网站的 B 部分详情,将根据《中央商品及服务税法》第 122 条、第 129 条和第 130 条启动处罚程序。
| Section |
Penalties for not carrying E-Way Bill |
| Sec 122(xiv) |
Penalty for a certain offense:
A taxable person, registered person, or any person who transports taxable goods without valid documents (i.e., E-Way Bill), shall be liable to a penalty of ₹10,000 or the tax sought to be evaded, whichever is higher.
|
| Sec 129 |
Detention, seizure, and release of goods and conveyance in transit
When goods are transported or stored in contravention of GST rules, they may be detained/seized. Release is subject to the following conditions:
If the owner comes forward to pay:
- Taxable goods: 100% of tax + penalty
- Exempt goods: 2% of value or ₹25,000 (whichever is less)
- OR furnish security equivalent to above
If the owner does NOT come forward:
- Taxable goods: 50% of value reduced by tax paid
- Exempt goods: 5% of value or ₹25,000 (whichever is less)
- OR furnish security equivalent to above
Additional safeguards:
- Order of detention/seizure must be served
- Opportunity of being heard is mandatory
- Provisional release possible upon execution of bond/security (Section 67(6))
- Payment of tax & penalty concludes proceedings
- Non-payment leads to action under Section 130
|
| Sec 130 |
Confiscation of goods and conveyance and levy of penalties
If tax and penalties are not paid within 7 days of detention/seizure:
- Goods and conveyance may be confiscated
- Penalty up to market value of goods (excluding tax)
- Penalty must be at least as much as in Sec 129(1)
- Opportunity of being heard must be given before confiscation
Reference: Interception of Conveyances
|
电子运单 - 北方邦
为何填写电子运单 B 部分至关重要
自 2018 年 11 月 1 日起,北方邦强制要求在电子运单之外加装 RFID 标签
拉贾斯坦邦电子运单